Friday 16 March 2012

Review posted on amazon.co.uk by Steluc Brooks

A serial killer stalks the streets of Newport and the police are powerless as neatly arranged corpses pile up like the flotsam on the River Usk. At times like these a hero is needed. Ed Wall, Newport's answer to Philip Marlow, finds his time has come. Can he prevent the serial killer striking again? We Go Down Slowly Rising, is the first novel by Welsh writer John Gimblett and on this showing, it is hoped that it's not the last.

The author follows a well-worn path taken by many writers of detective fiction. The story is played out against a backdrop familiar to the author and therefore written about with confidence. The decaying post-industrial sprawl of Newport becomes as important a backdrop to this novel as the gothic-noire Edinburgh of John Rebus, the dreaming spires and cosy pubs of Morse's Oxford or the bleak Scandinavian scenery of Wallander's Ystadt and this is one of the novel's great strengths.

Although it's not the first time South Wales has been used as a location for a crime novel, most notably with John William's Cardiff Trilogy, it's certainly the most convincing piece of work in the Welsh-noire sub-genre so far. We are taken on a journey through a city infused with familiar scenery, so often clearly visible in any modern British city. Urban decay, bawdy nightlife, civic artwork, the secret enclaves of diverse ethnicity and a grudging sense of community will resonate with the reader. In fact, they are the touchstones that underpin our love/hate relationship with urban life, a point well illustrated throughout this novel via the watchful eyes of Ed Wall. When seen from this perspective, the author has pulled off a remarkable feat, composing a love letter to an unlovely, but not unlovable city striking a chord with those of us who see the urban landscape of the modern city as a thing of both joy and sadness.

My interest was sustained throughout with a wealth of arcane facts which had me frequently turning to the internet to widen my knowledge on matters that ranged from the ley lines that cross this country to Newport's Jewish cemetery with much more in between. Whilst the narrative concentrates on Wall's quest to solve the murders, the author's attention to frequently quirky detail gives the novel a sense of individuality missing in more `by-the-numbers' crime fiction.

Like all private detectives Wall's love life is troubled. His relationships with the opposite sex teeters between the potency of desire and his inability to act, reflecting the paradox faced by many men of a 'certain age'. Wall's flesh might be all too willing, but his spirit is certainly weak. Sometimes he just appears to be exhausted. However, `love conquers Wall' and in one of the book's most satisfying subplots, Wall and Monica, a Polish forensic scientist, fall for each other over shots of industrial strength vodka and the quest to unmask the killer before another death by wren's feather takes place As with all the best hard-boiled fiction, there is always a soft centre.

The author's portrayal of Wall's nemesis is convincing, introducing us to a full blown sociopath who quotes poetry as he stalks the mean streets of Newport with a pocket full of wren's feathers and murder in his mind. It was interesting to note how alike Wall and the killer were: two outsiders who distanced themselves from the life going on around them as they prowled the city at all hours of the day and night. At times, Wall seems to be chasing a shadow of himself and on more than one occasion, I had to re-read a passage to check whether these were the thoughts of Wall or the killer. We get to know a lot about the killer's likes and dislikes, his formative childhood experiences and even his name. Intriguingly, his name is revealed long before the conclusion of this novel, a brave step which does nothing to diminish the suspenseful climax of the book. In fact, such was the convincing portrayal of the killer that I was left wanting to know more. At no point did we find out what the killer's motives were and I was slightly disappointed that we were left without a clue as to what made this killer act. Perhaps the author wanted to leave this deliberately vague to allow the reader to speculate.

We Go Down Slowly rising is an enjoyable read and I would recommend it to anyone who likes their crime fiction populated with cynical private detectives, clueless police, sinister killers and the redeeming power of love. It's what your Kindle was invented for!